Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula-3

 

We’ve got rain.  Well, a little anyway.  We started out the season ahead of the numbers but Mother Nature rested on her laurels and fell behind.  It’s been such a dry season…

So when the wind’s howling announced the rain’s arrival last night, my husband quickly prepared a fire as if to welcome a much-missed friend.  We’ll keep our fingers crossed that he sticks around for a while.

Meanwhile, in the kitchen, I prepared my own kind of welcome.  I reheated what was left of the batch of lentil soup I prepared this weekend.  We’ve enjoyed it for days and it’s just developed more flavor over time.  I’ll share the recipe with you on the next post.  For now here’s what rounded out the hearty meal last night.

I recreated a grilled cheese sandwich I enjoyed so much this weekend.  Sometimes the cravings can get quite strong (for me anyway) and one never fails to satisfy.  If I ever got into the habit of eating breakfast regularly, I’d be the girl who would turn down a tall stack of pancakes for a plate of toast with cheese.  As much as I like sweets, I’ll always be a savory girl at heart.  When cheese and bread are grilled together, I tend to keep it simple by just adding fresh tomato slices sprinkled with salt and pepper (and sometimes granulated garlic).

But other days call for something a bit more special.  I had an open jar of fig butter and a bag of fresh baby arugula in the refrigerator.  Upon seeing them I knew they’d go perfectly with the block of Irish cheddar I planned to use.  I grilled the sandwich the way I normally do, on my grill pan and weighted with a cast iron skillet to create those beautiful, appetizing grill marks.  I added the arugula tossed in fresh lemon juice and olive oil at the end.

Sweet, salty and peppery never tasted so good together.  As we took the first bites of our dinner in front of the fire last night the rain started to fall.  As we listened to the rain drops in my mind I said, “Stay awhile, old friend.  We’ve missed you.”

Notes:

  • You don’t have to use fig butter for this. Fig jam or any berry jam would work well, too.  
  • My cheese was still too cold and didn’t melt quickly so I covered the sandwich with my skillet part of the time as it grilled to speed up the melting process.  Alternatively, you can pop the sandwich (or just the cheese) in the microwave for a few seconds to soften it before you put it on the grill.
  • I prefer to use olive oil instead of butter for my grilled cheese sandwiches.

 

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula

Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula-2

 

4.5 from 2 reviews
Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
A plain grilled cheese sandwich always hits the spot but some days call for dressing it up by adding a few simple ingredients to make it just a bit more special.
Author:
Recipe type: Sandwich
Cuisine: American
Serves: 2
Ingredients
  • There are no exact measurements here. Adjust the list of ingredients according to the number people being served and how much you want to use of each.
  • Cheddar cheese, sliced (I used Irish cheddar)
  • Fig butter (I used the Trader Joe's brand but feel free to use fig or any other type of jam)
  • Bread slices (I used my favorite sliced bread: Beckmann's Three Seed Sourdough)
  • Baby arugula tossed in a little fresh lemon juice and olive oil
  • More olive oil for brushing bread (or cooking spray)
Instructions
  1. Use a heavy-bottomed skillet for this. I like to use my grill pan because of the pretty grill marks it creates. Preheat.
  2. Spread the fig butter on one of the bread slices, layer with cheese and top with the other slice of bread. Brush the outsides of the bread and place in the preheated pan. Grill over medium-high heat. Place another heavy pan (I used a cast iron skillet) on top of the sandwich and cook for 3-4 minutes on one side. Flip it over and do the same for the other side until the cheese has melted.
  3. Take the sandwich off the heat, add the the arugula tossed in lemon dressing and slice. Serve warm.
Notes
* You don't have to use fig butter for this. Fig jam or any berry jam would work well, too. * My cheese was still too cold and didn't melt quickly so I covered the sandwich with my skillet part of the time as it grilled to speed up the melting process. Alternatively, you can pop the sandwich (or just the cheese) in the microwave for a few seconds to soften it before you put it on the grill. * I prefer to use olive oil instead of butter for my grilled cheese sandwiches.

 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Comments

  1. Grilled cheese is the ultimate comfort food on a rainy evening! (We had panini on homemade sourdough last night :)). Great flavors here!

  2. I love grilled cheese sandwiches. I have some lilikoi butter (that’s passion fruit) I bet that would be a great addition. Yum I can’t wait to try it and maybe add bacon too.

  3. Just Pinned this recipe. Looks and sounds delicious!

  4. Suzanne says:

    Yum, this sounds like a comforting but different sandwich. I bet it was delicious with your soup.

  5. I could totally go for one of these lovely sandwiches right now! And as always, stunning photographs!

  6. This has to be the best take on a grilled cheese sandwich. Ever! Fig butter and Irish cheddar must make a scrumptious couple. :)

  7. Fig butter is totally new to me! Sounds interesting. :)

    And this is probably the classiest grilled cheese sandwich ever. Beautiful!

  8. Scrumptious! A gourmet grilled cheese.

    Cheers,

    Rosa

  9. Very YUMMY, another recipe for my “must try” list!

  10. I’m a savory girl through and through! Sounds amazing with sweet fig & peppery arugula – It’s dreary and chilly here and I have been totally craving grilled cheese. Me thinks I need to put that too-heavy Mario Batali cast iron grill pan to good use :)

  11. You always manage to make your food look delightful. That sandwich in particular oozing cheese is lovely.

  12. Wow-za, that’s a beautiful panini. I can go as far as saying that you’ve made the perfect panini!!! Nice grill marks, crunchy-looking, gooey cheese, lively greens…A nice meal overall! When can I come over? LOL

  13. What a gorgeous sandwich. Love the flavor combination of the fig and arugula. Very unique, but sounds wonderful!

  14. You had me at fig, my dear! I still have some fig jam, so I think I will be making this sandwich tomorrow for lunch!

  15. I want this now for breakfast!!! This is a seriously gorgeous sandwich. I never thought of using my grill pan…duh! Love the look it gives the sandwich. Have a great weekend, Jean!

  16. Jean – this is my kind of grilled cheese sandwich! You know how much I LOVE fig jam. I bet this was perfection on a plate. I enjoyed the rain storm we had, just hope we get a few more, so our summer is not too dry or water rationing. Enjoy your weekend!!!

  17. Mmm, fig and arugula pair together so well – I can almost taste this deliciousness!

    we are supposed to get rain today – perhaps I need to do this for lunch…

  18. Oh, my gosh. I love this combination.

  19. You had me at ‘fig’ – I love figs and anything made with figs. Cheese and figs go so well together and adding the arugula for a peppery bite sounds fabulous. I’ll be making these over the weekend to go with some yummy veggie soup that has been melding and getting all those lush winter veg flavors together.

    Thanks for a beautiful site and great food ideas.

Trackbacks

  1. […] From Lemon and Anchovies: Grilled cheese sandwich with fig butter and arugula […]

  2. […] grilled cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter  (via) — I desperately want to try this. […]

  3. […] Grilled Cheese Sandwich with Fig Butter and Arugula by Jean of Lemons and Anchovies     […]

Id Love to Hear from You

*

Rate this recipe: